Favourite Live Member of Marilyn Manson

[siphonchrysalis]

My Vote goes to John 5 for sure.
Quite easily the most dynamic and interesting on stage
2nd place to Ginger

[manniqueenbride]

pogo is just so damn hot, and he looks like he dont give a shit wich is always entertaining and attractive.

[Pretty Mess]

I voted Ginger, because he always puts all his energy and soul into his drumming, and always looks like hes having a great time doing so :)

[blackangel7]

GINGER FISH!!!!

[Burlesk]

John 5.

[wingenocide]

Pogo is always fun to watch because you dont know what he is gonna do, either bang his head and drink beer or get pissed and smash his keyboard or just stand there haha.. he is so cool

[Pretty Mess]

Pogo is always fun to watch because you dont know what he is gonna do, either bang his head and drink beer or get pissed and smash his keyboard or just stand there haha.. he is so cool

lol yeah I agree..hes a funny character Pogo

[Biohazard]

I'd vote for John 5, Pogo and Ginger. To me, they are the most entertaining when they are on the stage. John 5 keeps walking around while playing his guitar, Pogo keeps kicking and smashing his keyboard and Ginger just puts a huge lot of energy into his drumming... that's just awesome...

[Mr-Po-Go]

Madness. I've never noticed Ginger doing anything of particular note :S In fact I've rarely seen much of him at al, other than the occasional glimpse of his arms flying up in the air occasionly.

[Rx]

johns the man

Rx

[sAINTSCENE]

Pogo because he just hangs out in
the back and drinks a bear. The guy's
the man.

[[Digital Euphoria]]

Well Manson of course, right? no, oh ok.

[Angeles_mk3]

I voted for john 5 because he is my idol.

If i was allowed 2 votes I would have voted again for pogo because he gave me the 'sign of the devil' at manson's melbourne concert last year.

It was at the end of DDBBZZ when everything went quiet, and Pogo was looking at/checking something on his keyboard. I yelled out at the top of my voice 'YOU ROCK POGO!!!', I was right at the front against the barricade in front of John 5, and pogo looked up and made the sign to me.


Ahh happy Memories :)

[Tourniquet]

I voted for John 5, he was amazing live
Spitting in the crowd and jumping around,
And he smiled so great at me when I was singing , that was so awesome !!!
And his water of his bottle hit me :D

[pissed_ghost]

i don't think you should of put manson in the poll, it's just not fair.

[GunsOfBrixton]

Ruben Studdard.

[MissFoggie]

The star of course!

[Legato]

I went with manson but aside from him i gotta with (in this order)
Timmy
Ginger/John
Pogo

[comawhite]

My vote goes to Manson, closely followed by Tim, he was great when we went to see them, then again, so was John, hang on and Ginger and Pogo were.........shit, I got a headache now!!!!

[KaboomKaboom]

Originally posted by Mr-Po-Go
Madness. I've never noticed Ginger doing anything of particular note :S In fact I've rarely seen much of him at al, other than the occasional glimpse of his arms flying up in the air occasionly.

Well this is because you are not a drummer. Bein,g a drummer and playing the drums makes you know what it really consists in having your arms flying around all the time, standing up, and hitting your floor tom with your foot, while the rythms go on and you just can't miss out anything. This is hard job and long training.

[elektrosmog]

John 5 is cool :)

[RazoRayIsMe]

Pogo. I like how he gets pissed and smashes his keyboards.

[siphonchrysalis]

omg
john 5 at the sydney concert gave me the 'sign of the devil'
cause during TITNS i was the only one looking at him (i was right infront of manson 2 ppl bak from the barricade) and i was all in white (cause im not goth... surfer in fact who loves goth shit) and i was turned facing him
he also gave me an 'evil smile' walked in a circle, threw a pic at me which went way off the other way and then gave me the 'sign of the devil'
i was sooooo stoked

happiest moment of my life

i should have mentioned that before

[U$EFUL RU1N$]

J5 !

[snog]

marilyn.
when i'd seen the band perform during the ggg tour in nyc's hammerstein ballroom[across from penn station/madison square garden]i was impressed with manson's wonderful handling of theatrics.he does have real stage presence.was terribly amusing when he donned the vestments,too.i died laughing.
as for the other fellas,sorry,guys.i only had eyes for marilyn...

[The King]

Originally posted by siphonchrysalis
My Vote goes to John 5 for sure.
Quite easily the most dynamic and interesting on stage
2nd place to Ginger

^Great minds think alike!

I voted JOhn 5 also, same reasons siph did.

Anyone who votes for Pogo is gay.

All he does is swing his little keyboard around. Half of the time he doesn't even play it.

[Rhea Pennell]

At the show I attended, John didn't do much at all, just stood on his side of the stage and played.

[Morgaine]

Ginger, definatly, i started to learn how to drum and found out how hard it really is so i admire the was he drums (swaying those arms and standing on his drums)

[pissed_ghost]

i would say the dancers, they totally take my vote.

[BuzzBuzzZigZag]

Putting Manson in the list is a little unfair, I mean he's the ring leader isn't he?

TIM SKOLD

He and Manson were connecting through the whole gig I went to. And in a heavy bass riff he's drop his knees and bass down in time with the music, and I like his gloves and his soldier-boy hat. Oh, and during The Dope Show he bucked his bass right up, and the painted double bass was great too.

[mjknin]

Pogo.

[PaintMeBlue]

Originally posted by Scumpot
Putting Manson in the list is a little unfair, I mean he's the ring leader isn't he?

TIM SKOLD

He and Manson were connecting through the whole gig I went to. And in a heavy bass riff he's drop his knees and bass down in time with the music, and I like his gloves and his soldier-boy hat. Oh, and during The Dope Show he bucked his bass right up, and the painted double bass was great too.


same vote...same reason :)

[VodEvil]

Absolutely GINGER FISH... I see him in Portugal once, and it was really fucking amazing and very faster to. Really impressive...

[pwcca]

Manson himself of course. Without him there would be no Marilyn Manson. As we have seen over the past 10 years or so, the other band members are interchangable. So Manson gets my vote

[MAN3]

POGO GODDAMMIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[mgoldenagem]

john 5,

how he "head bangs" is the shit i love him on GGG on great big white world i think ginger fish is most down to earth i talked ot him at ozzfest this year it was awsome he interacted with every one signed my shirt and went to wacth ozzy and john 5 was kinda rude he signed my shirt but was more intrested in the girls but can ya fucking blame him hes the man

[Charles Monroe]

Manson of course... Allthough.. On stage he can be an asshole (remember The bEautiful People at Rock Am Ring)

After Manson I like John 5 the most. Why did he had to go? :'(

[Kalika]

voted for Manson I did.

[6dope6hate6]

Well other than Manson I would say Ginger Fish and being a drummer my self he makes things look very easy.

[Ramirez 425]

My vote would have to be twiggy..he's not a choice but he should be. Hes so fucking awesome. 2nd would be Skold tho.

[gesh]

My vote is for Ginger.
(are there any dead members?)
just a little dumb humor folks!!

[Twi_po_gein]

My Vote would have to go to Pogo just for his sure-Maddness and energy.... an unpridictable time bomb!

...KK33º...AD...

[+CrazyBitch+]

Manson!

[Dr_noswad]

Originally posted by Ramirez 425
My vote would have to be twiggy..he's not a choice but he should be. Hes so fucking awesome. 2nd would be Skold tho.

agreed, where the hell was Twiggy?

[angelsephiroth]

Between Skold and Manson, I dunno, I think Skold humping the stand-up bass was too hot to pass up.

[valleyofdeath]

Originally posted by sAINTSCENE
Pogo because he just hangs out in
the back and drinks a bear. The guy's
the man. well if he can drink a bear, I guess that is quite a preformance...0_o

[Sinnamon]

obviously its ginger.

[Tim Skold]

i go for skold.
just because at the show i attended he was really energetic and posing and dancin around and stuff.

[dave303]

ginger. slightly biased since i am a drummer, but i like his style. john is great live too

[WorkofArt]

Didnt you've seen Skolds Style? I like the way hes posing. But my eyes were on Manson...
I miss Twiggy!

[Mechantichrist]

Oh man, I definitely pick Tim. It gave me shivers when he came out last tour. He looked SO fake. I mean, whenever he would just freeze and pose like a mannequin I'd get shivers. It's just fucking amazing, and I love how he moves and shit.

[Vallerry]

Dudes i can't believe that Skold has only a few votes because he is the BEST. I mean ..... when u see him playing the bass like he's bored and the songs are like to easy 4 him it just makes me go crazy. He's the best , i repeat , the BEST. All the other guys that have been in the band (except 4 Twiggy) were so boring on stage. Oh well, i gues it's hard to be a bass player and to have a super live performance.

[OBSCENE]

Skold is just so goddamn good!
He deserves more votes!!
And he's from sweden to, a big plus :D

[Omega_3x5]

Originally posted by OBSCENE
Skold is just so goddamn good!
He deserves more votes!!
And he's from sweden to, a big plus :D

Good to see some Skold love :D

I voted Manson.

[iamthehydra]

The band Marilyn Manson cannot exists without Marilyn Manson himself. That's why I consider him the favourite member...

[Omega_3x5]

Originally posted by iamthehydra
The band Marilyn Manson cannot exists without Marilyn Manson himself. That's why I consider him the favourite member...

So true.

[ozebane]

John 5 has the most annoying stage presence of any member of anything ever. I fucking hate that stupid lets-sway-my-head-from-side-to-side-and-then-walk-around-in-a-circle thing he does.
If you're going to headbang, headbang instead of doing that stupid swaying thing.

Just needed to let that out.

[Omega_3x5]

Originally posted by ozebane
John 5 has the most annoying stage presence of any member of anything ever. I fucking hate that stupid lets-sway-my-head-from-side-to-side-and-then-walk-around-in-a-circle thing he does.
If you're going to headbang, headbang instead of doing that stupid swaying thing.

Just needed to let that out.

I liked the way that he shaked his head like he was mad...

Teach us how to headbang, Ozebane :O

[Sinnamon]

ginger. no contest.

[BloodofNothing]

Manson.... I always pay most attention to the vocalist.

[iamthehydra]

Originally posted by BloodofNothing
Manson.... I always pay most attention to the vocalist.



Yeap ! Me too...

[Brian_Warner]

My vote go to twiggy seeing how he was the most loved he should have been on the dame poll list. Tiggy needs to come back

[ace]

John 5 - love the way he plays the guitar so passionately.
Ginger Fish - love the way he plays the drums so passionately.

[Barbarella]

Voted for John 5 cos he has so much energy and is really passionate about playing. Pogo would be next as I can never take my eyes of him !!

[teegs]

hmm probably Ginger or John

[Vallerry]

Skold all the way. He looks 2 cool not to be the best.

[Alexander]

Manson. Of course.

2nd place: Pogo. When they played here, I went mad when I saw him tearing his keyboards in pieces.

[dave303]

Originally posted by sAINTSCENE
Pogo because he just hangs out in
the back and drinks a bear. The guy's
the man.


heh. pogo drinks bears

[Sinnamon]

ROAR!!! Grizzly Beers? lol~!!

[GODxEATxGOD]

John 5.
He improvised a lot and he just made the show great over and over again when he still was in the band

And his new album is AWESOME
So my vote goes to him, definately

[fed MM]

in AGG TOUR TIM SKOLD IS THE BEST MEMBERS....... IN THE BAND ....

GOOD MANSON.....
POGO NO ... :(

[Mercury SS]

Skold, hands down... (and panties too ;) )

[Dermagraft-TC]

Pogo has the funniest personality- Skold has great stage presence

[Skaboom]

Pogo

[Welovehate]

on Last tour?both Chaussee and Skold

[cyborg assassin]

Twiggy was pretty insane on stage. Pogo though is probably the coolest though.

[iwtv]

I miss Twiggy :( Should have been an option. Second to him, I voted for John5. I love the headwag he does during GGG.

[Wyjh]

Ginger of course, because of how passionate he is when playing.

Manson next, because he is the star and all that...

And then the rest. Nothing too spectacular with their performances, IMO.

[Ainsley]

The backup singers from the MA tour. <3

[Nil Three]

Zim Zum. I want Zim, John, and Daisy to get together and collectivley kill Mark.

[KMFDMsucks]

Voted for tim, hes got great stage presence. john looks like a pompous asshole, ginger and pogo dont really do anything and manson's just unfair

[Stephen Bitch]

Ginger rules. He plays really oddly, does some weird stuff with his arms. It;s not overcomplicated, but he's quite the showman.

[Ramirez 425]

grotesk burlesk- john 5
against all gods- tim skold

[virus]

Voted Ginger, but then i did used to play drums myself so tht cud b y. 2nd would by john5.

[neurotic]

voted pogo...only cause i like him so much plus seeing him on those keyboards is v.entertaining! (although not so much anymore, he just presses one key and drinks beer...)

of course manson gets the number one vote though.

[ElgantlyGrotesk]

Originally posted by cyborg assassin
Twiggy was pretty insane on stage.

He sure was, I am wondering what happened to that with NIN. Especially considering I find it hard to stand still when I play NIN on my guitar.

[The Rapture]

Since both of my favorite live members arent in the poll (Twiggy and Daisy) Im going with Skold. He's awesome.

[rheakurokawa]

Leaving Manson completely out of it, cause indeed it's rather unfair to have him there i'd say

Pogo and John5. I can't choose. They're both amazing to watch.
And Ginger is amazing too. It's very hard to pick.

[lowartgloomy]

Of course that would be Manson. I love that guy. But surely he couldn't do it without any of the other ones. John 5 is really great aswell.

[GodSlitMyWrists]

Fuck u Ozebane...
Timmy is from Sweden and I'm from Norway so I like him very much and I play bass myself.

But J5 is my all time IDOL!!!!

[Antioch]

John 5, Tim Skold, Pogo, Ginger Fish

[Meat & Cedar]

Originally posted by SpookyNobody
what about twiggy? i know he is not in the band anymore but he was great on stage You know I was just about to say that, but I figured I read to the end and what do you know. I'm not the only one. John5 isn't with them anymore either and his pompous arse is still in the poll. Why isn't twiggy? Why not fucking TWIGGY?
I vote twiggy.

[QuickSilver]

For me, it has always been Marilyn Manson all the way. Truth of the matter is, although they certainly are a great band and make wonderful music together, I couldn't care less about the others.

I have a soft spot for Manson. I love everything about him, always have, always will.

[Scar Shock]

1. Marilyn Manson
2. John 5 (WHY DID YOU LEAVE THE BAND?)
3. Twiggy Ramirez (AND WHY DID YOU LEAVE THE BAND?)
4. Ginger Fish
5. Madonna Wayne Gacy

[Iphigora]

I voted for Skold, I think his style is damn cool. Plus i adore his past stuff so that's a soft spot for me. I have a thing for the bassist. Plus he's Swedish, and I love Sweds.

By the way stop yelling about leaving Twiggy off. I think it should have been current line-up. Becuase it's grand and all you love Twiggy but that doesn't say much about the future now does it?

And don't say I don't like Jeordie or John, I seriously do, but it would be cooler if you just did it with the current band. With Mark as an option because as of yet we have no idea who the guitarist will be.

[darkcircling]

I'd vote Twiggy, but John 5 is my favorite of the current lineup.

[Barbarella]

Originally posted by darkcircling
I'd vote Twiggy, but John 5 is my favorite of the current lineup.

John5 has left the band.

[Kiddie Grinder]

Originally posted by darkcircling
I'd vote Twiggy, but John 5 is my favorite of the current lineup.

Originally posted by Barbarella
John5 has left the band.

LOL!!

[Meat & Cedar]

What is lol is I saw him touring with Zombie and I overheard some guy saying "OMG is that Ozzy Osbourne?"

[ironicchronic]

manson all the way, Dead to the World he just kicks ass, watched it on dvd last night, great imagery.

[profane]

Originally posted by ironicchronic
Dead to the World he just kicks ass, watched it on dvd last night
Yup, with many thanks to Mr. EatYourGod :)

[Damian]

Originally posted by profane
Yup, with many thanks to Mr. EatYourGod :)
I want one :( My tape is all worn out and shitty sounding.

[ironicchronic]

Originally posted by profane
Yup, with many thanks to Mr. EatYourGod :)
yes, thanks man